You are signed in. Close

You are signed out. Close

Thank you. Your subscription has started. Close

Thank you. You will get an email when a new comic comes out. Close

We could not confirm your payment. If you paid, use the link "Sign in" at the bottom of the page. Close

Something went wrong on our side. Please try again in a moment. Close

Previous episode Watch time: what TikTok learns from one quick swipe

How TikTok and YouTube decide what you see next

Clickbait vs watch time: why YouTube stopped trusting the click

In 2012, YouTube started to count how long people watch each video. At once, views on the site went down by 20%, and YouTube did this on purpose. What was wrong with counting clicks?

  1. 1 Picture yourself on YouTube in 2011, looking for the Wimbledon highlights. The preview picture of a video promises the best points of the match, and you click.Wimbledon:the best points!clickyou

    Picture yourself on YouTube in 2011, looking for the Wimbledon highlights. The preview picture of a video promises the best points of the match, and you click.

  2. 2 Instead, someone in their bedroom talks about the match. You leave after a few seconds. Too late: your click was counted, and back then, clicks were what YouTube counted most.So, aboutthat match0:08you

    Instead, someone in their bedroom talks about the match. You leave after a few seconds. Too late: your click was counted, and back then, clicks were what YouTube counted most.

  3. 3 So the next suggestion is another one like it, and then another. Counting clicks rewards the best picture, not the best video. A picture made only to get the click has a name: clickbait.clicks: 1clicks: 2clicks: 3clickbait

    So the next suggestion is another one like it, and then another. Counting clicks rewards the best picture, not the best video. A picture made only to get the click has a name: clickbait.

  4. 4 In 2012, YouTube began to count watch time too. The video you leave after a few seconds stops looking good, and the highlights you watch for twenty minutes rise.0:0820:00clickbaitthe highlights

    In 2012, YouTube began to count watch time too. The video you leave after a few seconds stops looking good, and the highlights you watch for twenty minutes rise.

  5. 5 Views on YouTube dropped by 20% at once. YouTube kept the change anyway: it wanted videos people watch, not videos people only click. Ever since, how long people watch has been one of the main signals of video feeds.views−20%

    Views on YouTube dropped by 20% at once. YouTube kept the change anyway: it wanted videos people watch, not videos people only click. Ever since, how long people watch has been one of the main signals of video feeds.

  6. 6 Back on your bus, the clock has told the app one thing: you like Miva's bowl. To show you more like it, it first has to know which videos are alike.????

    Back on your bus, the clock has told the app one thing: you like Miva's bowl. To show you more like it, it first has to know which videos are alike.

  7. Quick check

    A thrilling picture, or a long watch?Video A: a thrilling picture,most people leave after 3 s.Video B: a dull picture,people stay 10 minutes.Which one does a feed thatcounts watch time show more?

    A thrilling picture, or a long watch?

    Show the answer

    The one with the dull picture. The time people stay counts more than the click on the picture.

  8. Go further

    Valued watch time, and what YouTube's engineers wrote.valued watch timeYouTube asks some viewersto rate a video from 1 to 5stars, and counts the timespent on those rated 4 or 5the 2016 paperYouTube engineers wrotethat ranking by clickspromotes clickbait, so theyranked by guessed watch time

    Valued watch time, and what YouTube's engineers wrote.

Next episode Embeddings: how a video feed turns you and every video into numbers

Share this comic

More comics