You are signed in. Close

You are signed out. Close

Thank you. Your subscription has started. Close

Thank you. You will get an email when a new comic comes out. Close

We could not confirm your payment. If you paid, use the link "Sign in" at the bottom of the page. Close

Something went wrong on our side. Please try again in a moment. Close

Goodhart's law: why a number stops telling the truth once it becomes a target

Proxy metrics: why you watch a number instead of the goal

Your boss wants to know if customers get help, and nobody can read every support chat. So you watch one number that stands in for the goal: a proxy metric. When does it tell the truth?

  1. 1 In your city, people rent bikes with an app. When a lock jams, the rider writes to support, often from the street and in a hurry.a riderThe lock won'topen, andI'm late!

    In your city, people rent bikes with an app. When a lock jams, the rider writes to support, often from the street and in a hurry.

  2. 2 You run that support team, where Miva and Rono answer the riders. Each rider's problem, from the first message until it's solved, is a ticket.a ticketlock jammedpayment failedMivaRonoyou

    You run that support team, where Miva and Rono answer the riders. Each rider's problem, from the first message until it's solved, is a ticket.

  3. 3 Your boss wants one number for the monthly report. Far too many tickets come in for you to read them all, so where would that number come from?Are ridersgetting help?One number,please.your bossyou

    Your boss wants one number for the monthly report. Far too many tickets come in for you to read them all, so where would that number come from?

  4. 4 Luckily, the app already times every ticket, from the first message to solved. A number like this, one you watch to follow your work, is a metric.The app countsthis one for me.youtime to close9 hoursexample numbers

    Luckily, the app already times every ticket, from the first message to solved. A number like this, one you watch to follow your work, is a metric.

  5. 5 From your desk, you can't see a rider back on a bike. But a ticket closed fast usually means one, so the time stands in for the goal. That makes it a proxy, and so far a good one.the goal: riders helpedthe proxytime to closeusually moveswith the goalyou

    From your desk, you can't see a rider back on a bike. But a ticket closed fast usually means one, so the time stands in for the goal. That makes it a proxy, and so far a good one.

  6. 6 Nine hours still feels slow, so you pin up a bonus: the fastest closer of the month wins. From Monday, the proxy pays.Bonus: fastestcloser of the monthyouMivaRono

    Nine hours still feels slow, so you pin up a bonus: the fastest closer of the month wins. From Monday, the proxy pays.

  7. Go further

    The word your boss may use for that one number.KPIkey performanceindicator: one ofthe few metrics acompany picks toreport on, like theone your boss wants

    The word your boss may use for that one number.

Next episode Gaming a metric: the number gets better while the goal gets worse

Share this comic

More comics