You are signed in. Close

You are signed out. Close

Thank you. Your subscription has started. Close

Thank you. You will get an email when a new comic comes out. Close

We could not confirm your payment. If you paid, use the link "Sign in" at the bottom of the page. Close

Something went wrong on our side. Please try again in a moment. Close

Previous episode Exponential vs linear growth: why your brain guesses so low

The rice and chessboard problem: why exponential growth fools your brain

The lily pond riddle: why exponential growth gives almost no warning

Lily pads cover a pond, and every day there are twice as many. The pond is full on day 30. On which day was it half full? The quick answer is wrong, and the right one shows why anything that doubles looks harmless until the very end.

  1. 1 It is Miva, Rono's neighbour. She teaches maths, and when she hears about the rice, she has a riddle for you.MivaA riddle for you!youRono

    It is Miva, Rono's neighbour. She teaches maths, and when she hears about the rice, she has a riddle for you.

  2. 2 It is about a pond. On day 1, there is one lily pad on it. Every day, the number of pads doubles. On day 30, the pond is full.day 1day 30: fulltwice as many pads every day

    It is about a pond. On day 1, there is one lily pad on it. Every day, the number of pads doubles. On day 30, the pond is full.

  3. 3 When was the pond half full? You answer at once: day 15, half of 30. Your brain did it again: it cut a straight line in two.youDay 15!Miva

    When was the pond half full? You answer at once: day 15, half of 30. Your brain did it again: it cut a straight line in two.

  4. 4 Miva shakes her head. The pads double every day. So the day before the pond was full, it was half full: day 29.day 29: half fullday 30: full

    Miva shakes her head. The pads double every day. So the day before the pond was full, it was half full: day 29.

  5. 5 Go back a few more days. On day 25, the pads cover only 3 parts in 100 of the pond. A walker would see a pond with a few leaves. Five days later, there is no water left to see.day 25day 26day 27day 28day 29day 303 in 100 covered

    Go back a few more days. On day 25, the pads cover only 3 parts in 100 of the pond. A walker would see a pond with a few leaves. Five days later, there is no water left to see.

  6. 6 So the size of the pads today tells you little. What tells you more is how fast they double. Here it is once a day. This time is called the doubling time.1 daythe doubling time

    So the size of the pads today tells you little. What tells you more is how fast they double. Here it is once a day. This time is called the doubling time.

  7. 7 Rono goes quiet. On his fridge hangs the bill of his credit card. Miva tells him that a debt can grow like her lily pads.credit card billRonoMiva

    Rono goes quiet. On his fridge hangs the bill of his credit card. Miva tells him that a debt can grow like her lily pads.

  8. Quick check

    A pond with a head start.This pond starts with2 pads on day 1, and theydouble every day too.On which day is it full?

    A pond with a head start.

    Show the answer

    Day 29. Starting with 2 pads is like starting one doubling ahead, so everything happens one day sooner.

  9. Go further

    Where the riddle went, and real ponds.1972The Limits to Growtha 1972 book about the peopleand the resources of the world.It used this riddle to show howlate the warning comesreal lily padsthey grow fast, but not asneatly as a riddle: they donot double every day

    Where the riddle went, and real ponds.

Next episode Doubling time: the exponential growth hidden in compound interest and outbreaks

Share this comic

More comics