You are signed in. Close

You are signed out. Close

Thank you. Your subscription has started. Close

Thank you. You will get an email when a new comic comes out. Close

We could not confirm your payment. If you paid, use the link "Sign in" at the bottom of the page. Close

Something went wrong on our side. Please try again in a moment. Close

How ChatGPT and other AI chatbots answer your question

AI chatbots: why the answer is written for you, not looked up

You ask a chatbot like ChatGPT a question. A sure answer appears on your screen in seconds. A search engine finds pages, but the chatbot did not find this answer on any page. So where did the words come from?

  1. 1 Your plant is losing its leaves, so you ask a chatbot such as ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini, and press Send.My plant is losing its leaves.Should I water it more?you

    Your plant is losing its leaves, so you ask a chatbot such as ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini, and press Send.

  2. 2 Your friend Miva types the same question into a search engine like Google. It hands her links to pages that people wrote before she asked.Mivasearch engineHere are pagesthat already exist.written beforeshe asked

    Your friend Miva types the same question into a search engine like Google. It hands her links to pages that people wrote before she asked.

  3. 3 Your chatbot, the app you type in, works another way: it writes none of the answer. It sends your question away, over the internet.over theinternetNot my job toanswer. Off it goes!the chatbot

    Your chatbot, the app you type in, works another way: it writes none of the answer. It sends your question away, over the internet.

  4. 4 Your question lands in a data centre, a building full of computers, maybe in another country. A program there reads it: a large language model, or LLM.a data centreA plant question.Let me write!large language model (LLM)

    Your question lands in a data centre, a building full of computers, maybe in another country. A program there reads it: a large language model, or LLM.

  5. 5 The model then writes an answer for you, one word after another. It copies no page: it makes the sentence as it goes.the modelCheck, the, soil.Next word?Checkthesoilexample answer

    The model then writes an answer for you, one word after another. It copies no page: it makes the sentence as it goes.

  6. 6 The words travel back the same way, and the chatbot shows them on your screen.Should I waterit more?Check thesoil first.youGot it!

    The words travel back the same way, and the chatbot shows them on your screen.

  7. 7 But look at what reached the model: your question, under a lot more text that you never typed.your questionnot typedby youthe modelYour question.And all this?

    But look at what reached the model: your question, under a lot more text that you never typed.

  8. Quick check

    A new request, the same trip.You ask a chatbotfor a poem aboutyour cat, Pixel.Where was the poembefore youpressed Send?

    A new request, the same trip.

    Show the answer

    Nowhere yet. A model in a data centre wrote it for you, word after word, and the chatbot brought it back to your screen.

  9. Go further

    What the letters LLM stand for, and chatbots that search the web.large languagemodel, LLMLanguage: it works withtext. Large: billions ofnumbers inside it sethow it writesweb searchSome chatbots fetch webpages when the modelasks. The model readsthem and still writesthe answer itself

    What the letters LLM stand for, and chatbots that search the web.

Next episode System prompt: the hidden text an AI chatbot adds to your question

Share this comic

More comics